A Southern Australia Red Blend

Robert Parker gave it a 91...

D'Arenberg Shiraz Grenache

OUR WINE REVIEW POLICY All wines that we taste and review are purchased at the full retail price.

Wine Reviewed
D’Arenberg D’Arry’s Original 2004 13.0% alcohol about $15

Let’s start by quoting the marketing materials. Description : A perennial favorite of Robert Parker Jr., the 2004 earned a 91 (his web site, Oct. 2006). This Grenache/Shiraz blend displays aromas and flavors of blackberry, black cherry, cinnamon, roses, and menthol with coffee and caramel in the background. The wine lands softly on the palate, and finishes long and smooth. And now for my review.

There was a bottle cap problem; I needed a wrench to twist open the cap after cutting it. At the first sips this wine showed harsh acidity. So it tried it without food on the following day to see if this near defect would go away. It did, and I tasted caramel and dark plums. My first meal was a boxed vegetarian lasagna containing ricotta and mozzarella cheese. I slathered it with grated parmesan cheese. At first I noted a harshness in the wine’s acidity. As the meal went on, the harshness predominated. This was really too bad because the blend displayed lots of good fruit, oak, and caramel.

The next meal was chili with rice and okra cooked in tomato sauce and coriander. When it accompanied the meat, this wine’s caramel was predominant. Now its acidity was well balanced with light tannins. The delicious okra rounded out the caramel and the wine seemed slightly more tannic which was not a problem. I added ground chili peppers to the meat dish and the Grenache/Shiraz became more intense. The caramel stepped back to make room for black fruit. I don’t know about you, but I would rather taste black fruit than caramel in my dry wine. Dessert was fresh honeydew and the caramel taste was in the saddle.

My final meal centered around slow-cooked beef ribs accompanied by chickpeas. The wine was very long and mouth-filling; its caramel was surrounded by fruit. The chickpeas increased the wine’s acidity and intensified the caramel taste. When accompanying a tomato, onion, green pepper, artichoke, and jalapeno, lime salsa the wine lost fruit even as it echoed the salsa’s acidity.

My first cheese was a marbled cheddar. This blend was quite long and round, tasting of, you guessed it, caramel. With a more interesting Swiss cheese the wine’s acidity was slightly harsh, not as bad as in the beginning.

Final verdict. I not would buy this wine again, I was unhappy with the initial harsh acidity and all that caramel. Seeing it on the web for $13 doesn’t change my mind.

Access the companion wine A Southeastern Australia Kosher Red Blend (Under $10)

About the Author

Levi Reiss has authored or co-authored ten books on computers and the Internet, but to be honest, he would rather just drink fine Italian or other wine, accompanied by the right foods. He teaches classes in computers at an Ontario French-language community college. His wine websites include
www.theworldwidewine.com    and    http://www.wineinyourdiet.com

Visit his website devoted to Italian travel www.travelitalytravel.com

Feel free to reprint this entire article which must include the resource box